The 25-year-old actress celebrated the romantic occasion at the Commodore bar in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, with the 32-year-old comic and the pair seemed to be having a great time together.
Jennifer and Aziz had reserved a corner of the bar and spent the evening laughing and chatting over a bottle of wine, though onlookers insisted they didn’t seem to be more than ”really good friends.”
A source told People magazine: ”They looked friendly and were showing each other stuff on their iPhones and chatting and laughing.
”They tried lots of different food and looked like they had a lot of fun. They looked like really good friends.”
And The Hunger Games star – who previously dated actor Nicholas Hoult and Coldplay frontman Chris Martin – ensured she preserved a memory of the evening by asking a bartender to take a photo of herself and Aziz on her phone.
The pair were previously seen together late last year, when Jennifer gave Aziz – who split from chef Courtney McBroom in January – a piggyback ride when they left a Saturday Night Live afterparty in October when their mutual pal Amy Schumer had hosted the show.
The also spent time with one another in Atlanta, along with Amy, shortly afterwards, and the trio enjoyed Thanksgiving together.