A Love Song for Bobby Long (2004)

The quiet, intimate drama A Love Song for Bobby Long features Scarlett in one of the lead roles. She plays Pursy, a young woman who returns to New Orleans in the wake of her mother's death with aims of reclaiming her childhood home. However, she arrives to encounter two men (John Travolta, Gabriel Macht) inhabiting the house and is forced to reevaluate her plans. For her supreme work in the film, Scarlett picked up her third Golden Globe nomination.