Rumer Willis celebrated her 24th birthday last Thursday without her mother, Demi Moore.
The actress was treated to a meal at Abe & Arthur's in New York's Meatpacking District with her sisters Tallulah and Scout, and her father Bruce Willis joined them halfway through the meal.
However, Rumer's mother Demi Moore was noticeably absent from the celebrations, fuelling rumors of a rift.
An eye witness told the New York Post
: "He (Bruce) helped them sing 'Happy Birthday' to Rumer and blow out the candles."
The Die Hard
actor said his goodbyes to the girls as they headed downstairs to party the night away at SL lounge.
They were joined by Rumer's roommate Annie Starke - who is Glenn Close's daughter
- and her new boyfriend Jayson Blair.
The star posted a series of pictures on twitter, saying: "Happy Birthday Me ... with my two favorite people @anniestarke1 and @jayson_blair (sic)."
Demi has been troubled since last November following her split from Ashton Kutcher and went to rehab for issues including an eating disorder, exhaustion and substance abuse.