No Stranger Than Love

Just as art teacher Lucy (Alison Brie) is about to make love to her married colleague Clint (Colin Hanks), a three-foot hole opens up at his feet. He plummets into a black abyss where he remains, but he's unharmed and is able to communicate from his newfound home.

Before Lucy can pull together a rescue plan, she needs to devise an explanation for Clint's absence. When tough guy Rydell (Justin Chatwin) rides into town looking for Clint to collect on a gambling debt, he seems like the prime person to pin the mystery on. Lucy's plan is thrown for a loop, though, when she begins developing feelings for Rydell.